Admit it, when it comes to
the NFL’s replacement officials, you probably fall into one of four categories:
- You mock them, laughing hysterically at some of the boneheaded calls from the preseason (that’s a touchback … the 4-yard line!).
- You are freaked out, fearing the day they blow a big, game-changing call against your favorite team.
- You, like many NFL fans, think you could do a better job. Of course, you felt that way with the “real” refs, too. (One inexplicable call a game isn’t looking so bad in comparison, huh?)
- Your only concern is how this is going to affect your fantasy team.
But what happens when one of
the less-experienced officials allows an illegal, season-ending hit on Dez
Bryant, Randy Moss, Larry Fitzgerald or another defenseless receiver?
How will you feel, Ravens or
Jets fans, when Steelers linebacker James Harrison comes flying, unimpeded, at
Joe Flacco or Mark Sanchez with a helmet-first tackle that knocks the air out
of your QB but doesn’t draw a flag?
And Vikings fans, how will
you feel when AP’s banged-up knee is reinjured because less-experienced officials
let a gang-tackle continue long after the play should have been blown dead?
While many fans have found
preseason officiating alternately funny and frustrating, what really concerns
me is the safety factor. In a league
where two of its biggest headlines—touchdowns and concussions—often appear in
the same news stories, the NFL needs to avoid a situation where its bone headedness could have a negative
impact on the health of its players.
Over the past decade, the
NFL has created a lot of good will in making its product safer for its players.
What’s more, many of the league’s more experienced officials have been heavily
involved in the process and can be partly credited with keeping the NFL’s
biggest asset—its players—safe. It is a goal in which both sides are heavily
invested.
While it has become sport to
make fun of the replacement officials, we must remember two important things:
First, the replacements are doing the best they can, considering the
circumstances. In most cases, officials start out at a lower level, moving up
and gaining experience along the way. But these people took an express train to
the NFL, bypassing a handful of stops. Can you imagine getting a job in the
mailroom one day and then getting an opportunity to step in as president a
short time later? There would be a bit of a learning curve, to say the least.
These officials did more than just yell at the TV from the couch, like most
fans do. They were offered a chance of a lifetime, and they took it.
Secondly, let’s be clear—this
is a mistake on the NFL’s part (i.e., the league should be the butt of the
jokes, not the officials). If the underlying issue is partly about money, the
NFL has the most to lose. In the long run, ensuring the safety of the game is
worth far more than the NFL could ever concede to the referee’s union.